• About Us
  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
  • DMCA
  • Follow on Google News
Monday, November 16, 2026
  • Login
North East India
  • Home
  • North East News
  • India
    • National
    • State News
  • World
  • Business
  • Education
  • Entertainment
  • Lifestyle
    • Health & Fitness
    • Fashion & Beauty
    • Travel
    • Food
    • Photography
  • Tech
    • App News
    • Gadgets
  • Others
    • Auto
    • Sports
    • Agriculture
    • Science
    • Astrology
    • Finance/Money
    • Press Release
    • Religion
No Result
View All Result
North East India
No Result
View All Result
Dr Srabani Basu

When Women Must Become Men to Be Heard: The Psychology of Performed Masculinity

by North East India
November 16, 2026
in Lifestyle
Reading Time: 6 mins read
0

Dr Srabani Basu, Associate Professor, Department of Literature and Languages, SRM University AP


Are women becoming more masculine, or are they adapting to a world that continues to define power in masculine terms?

YOU MAY ALSO LIKE

The Never-Enough Generation – Why Getting More No Longer Makes Us Happier?

Beyond Ranthambore: Madhya Pradesh’s Quiet Wildlife Tourism Boom

A woman speaks firmly during a meeting and is described as aggressive. A man expresses the same opinion with comparable conviction and is admired for his assertiveness. A woman refuses an unreasonable demand and is labelled difficult. A man establishes an identical boundary and earns respect for his professionalism. Somewhere within these seemingly ordinary interactions lies a peculiar contradiction. Women are encouraged to become independent, ambitious, and powerful, yet frequently discover that the behavioural language of power has already been written in masculine terms. Consequently, many women learn to negotiate authority by performing behaviours traditionally associated with masculinity. The question is whether this represents liberation, adaptation, or another sophisticated form of social conditioning.

For generations, women were encouraged to embody gentleness, accommodation, emotional availability, and selflessness. These qualities were celebrated as virtues yet often became instruments through which women’s boundaries were negotiated away. When women entered professional spaces historically dominated by men, they encountered a different behavioural vocabulary. Authority demanded assertiveness, decisiveness, competitiveness, and emotional restraint. The underlying message was contradictory. Women could participate in positions of power, provided they demonstrated qualities that conventional gender expectations had rarely permitted them to claim.

Psychologically, this phenomenon can be understood through the distinction between identity and adaptation. Human beings continuously modify their behaviour in response to environmental expectations. Albert Bandura’s social learning theory explains how behaviours are acquired through observation, reinforcement, and perceived consequences. When women repeatedly observe that assertiveness receives recognition while accommodation invites exploitation, they may begin adopting more dominant behavioural strategies. Such adaptation is not necessarily evidence of an altered identity. It may simply reflect learning within an environment where particular behaviours are rewarded.

Judith Butler’s theory of gender performativity provides another illuminating perspective. Gender is continually reproduced through repeated behaviours, gestures, and social expectations. If masculinity has historically been associated with authority, then performing authority may inadvertently require women to reproduce masculine-coded behaviours. However, this does not establish that assertiveness, independence, or decisiveness inherently belong to men. Rather, it reveals how human capacities have been artificially assigned gender identities.

The psychological complexity deepens when we examine role congruity theory, developed by Alice Eagly and Steven Karau. Their framework explains how prejudice emerges when expectations associated with a social group appear incompatible with expectations attached to a particular role. Women are traditionally expected to demonstrate communal qualities such as warmth and cooperation, while leaders are often expected to demonstrate agentic qualities such as dominance and assertiveness. A woman aspiring to leadership may therefore confront conflicting expectations. If she behaves communally, her competence may be questioned. If she behaves assertively, her likeability may suffer.

This creates a psychological double bind. Women must appear sufficiently assertive to establish authority without becoming so assertive that they violate expectations of femininity. They must demonstrate confidence without appearing intimidating, independence without seeming uncooperative, and emotional strength without being perceived as cold. The psychological burden lies not merely in performing leadership but in continuously monitoring how that performance is being interpreted.

Over time, such monitoring can produce heightened self-consciousness, emotional exhaustion, and identity conflict. A woman may begin questioning whether she is behaving authentically or merely reproducing the behavioural characteristics required for acceptance. Her professional identity may gradually become organised around anticipated evaluations rather than personal preferences.

Psychologist Madeline Heilman’s research on gender stereotypes helps explain this tension. Women can encounter penalties not only when they are perceived as insufficiently competent but also when they demonstrate competence through behaviours that contradict traditional feminine expectations. The paradox is striking. Success does not necessarily release women from gender expectations. Sometimes, it intensifies the pressure to manage them.

Yet another psychological mechanism deserves consideration: defensive adaptation. Individuals who repeatedly experience dismissal, exclusion, or disrespect may develop protective behavioural strategies. Emotional distance, rigid boundaries, excessive self-reliance, and heightened control can sometimes emerge as responses to environments perceived as threatening or dismissive. These behaviours are not exclusively feminine or masculine. Nevertheless, when displayed by women, they are frequently interpreted as evidence of becoming masculine.

Consider a woman who has repeatedly discovered that kindness is mistaken for compliance. She may gradually replace spontaneous warmth with calculated reserve. Another woman whose opinions have routinely been overlooked may begin speaking with greater force. Someone whose vulnerability has been exploited may become fiercely independent. The outward transformation can resemble stereotypical masculinity, although its psychological origins may lie in self-protection rather than identification with masculine ideals.

However, we must distinguish healthy assertiveness from defensive rigidity. Establishing boundaries, exercising autonomy, and expressing disagreement are essential psychological capabilities. They do not represent the abandonment of femininity. Problems arise when individuals begin believing that emotional openness, dependence, or tenderness inevitably jeopardise their safety or authority.

Economic realities can reinforce these adaptations. Financial independence provides women with greater opportunities for choice, mobility, and personal autonomy. Yet economic participation also occurs within systems where productivity, competition, availability, and performance are frequently prioritised over emotional or relational considerations. Women navigating professional ambitions alongside family responsibilities may experience competing demands upon their time, energy, and identities.

Consequently, the performance of toughness can become a practical survival strategy. A woman may feel compelled to appear exceptionally capable, endlessly resilient, and perpetually available because acknowledging exhaustion could be interpreted as professional inadequacy. What appears externally as empowerment may sometimes conceal the psychological cost of having to prove competence repeatedly.

The politics of roles adds another dimension. Power is not exercised exclusively through formal positions. It operates through everyday expectations concerning who speaks, who decides, whose opinions carry authority, and whose emotions receive legitimacy. Within families, workplaces, and institutions, women may discover that occupying a role does not automatically guarantee recognition within that role.

A woman may possess authority on paper yet find herself continuously negotiating the right to exercise it. She may be required to justify decisions more extensively, establish credibility repeatedly, or demonstrate greater emotional restraint to secure equivalent recognition. In such circumstances, adopting traditionally masculine behaviours can become less a personal preference than a calculated response to unequal expectations.

Interestingly, this adaptation can occasionally reproduce the very structures women struggle against. A woman who has succeeded by suppressing vulnerability may begin demanding identical suppression from other women. Someone who has achieved authority through relentless competitiveness may interpret collaboration as weakness. A leader who survived exclusion through emotional detachment may inadvertently establish a workplace culture where emotional openness remains unwelcome.

This is where the psychology of internalisation becomes particularly relevant. When individuals repeatedly conform to a system’s expectations, they may eventually mistake those expectations for universal standards of competence. The behavioural strategy that initially helped them navigate a restrictive environment can become the measure by which they judge themselves and others.

Yet it would be equally misleading to assume that every assertive, ambitious, or emotionally reserved woman is performing masculinity. Some women naturally prefer direct communication, competition, independence, or analytical detachment. Personality differences cannot be reduced to gender conditioning. The problem is not that women display these characteristics. The problem is that society continues to categorise them as masculine.

Perhaps the deeper issue, therefore, is not why women are becoming masculine, but why authority continues to be imagined through a masculine lens.

True psychological empowerment does not require women to abandon tenderness any more than it requires men to abandon vulnerability. It involves expanding the individual’s freedom to choose behaviours according to circumstances, values, and personal authenticity rather than prescribed gender identities.

Leadership, similarly, must move beyond the assumption that firmness and compassion are incompatible. Effective authority can accommodate decisiveness without domination, empathy without submission, independence without isolation, and vulnerability without helplessness. These are not masculine or feminine combinations. They are expressions of psychological maturity.

Perhaps we have misunderstood the evolution of women’s empowerment. We celebrate women for becoming stronger, tougher, and more independent without always examining the conditions that made such performances necessary. We applaud their resilience while overlooking the environments that continuously demand it.

The greatest achievement would not be creating women who can successfully perform masculinity. It would be creating environments where women no longer need to perform anything beyond their authentic capabilities.

Liberation does not occur when women finally learn to behave like men. It occurs when neither women nor men must imitate a prescribed gender identity to be respected, recognised, or heard.

Tags: Dr Srabani Basu
ShareTweetSharePinSendShare
Previous Post

Dnyaan Prasad Global University (DPGU), Pune, Offers Students a Global Learning Experience in the UAE Through Joint Certification and Corporate Exposure

Related Posts

Dr. Pavithra .M R,
Lifestyle

The Never-Enough Generation – Why Getting More No Longer Makes Us Happier?

by North East India
November 2, 2026
Beyond Ranthambore: Madhya Pradesh’s Quiet Wildlife Tourism Boom
Travel

Beyond Ranthambore: Madhya Pradesh’s Quiet Wildlife Tourism Boom

by North East India
July 22, 2026
High Voltage Campaign from Lotus Herbals for India’s First HydroActivated Sunscreen
Lifestyle

High Voltage Campaign from Lotus Herbals for India’s First HydroActivated Sunscreen

by North East India
April 9, 2026
Lotus Derma Botanics unveils its debut campaign for it’s Blemish Free Face Wash
Lifestyle

Lotus Derma Botanics unveils its debut campaign for it’s Blemish Free Face Wash

by North East India
December 3, 2025
Meet Ritanya Kaushik: The 9-Year-Old Child Prodigy Blending Innovation, Art, and Academics with Grace
Lifestyle

Meet Ritanya Kaushik: The 9-Year-Old Child Prodigy Blending Innovation, Art, and Academics with Grace

by North East India
October 15, 2025
Lotus Herbals Unveils New Campaign for Its Iconic White Glow Gel Crème
Lifestyle

Lotus Herbals Unveils New Campaign for Its Iconic White Glow Gel Crème

by North East India
October 9, 2025
Five Years of Excellence: How Tara Healthcare is Redefining Plastic Surgery in Bangalore 
Health & Fitness

Five Years of Excellence: How Tara Healthcare is Redefining Plastic Surgery in Bangalore 

by North East India
September 20, 2025
Unity World Pageants Season 3 Crowned a Global Triumph of Beauty, Talent & Advocacy
Lifestyle

Unity World Pageants Season 3 Crowned a Global Triumph of Beauty, Talent & Advocacy

by North East India
September 20, 2025

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Search

No Result
View All Result

Recent News

Dr Srabani Basu

When Women Must Become Men to Be Heard: The Psychology of Performed Masculinity

November 16, 2026
Dnyaan Prasad Global University (DPGU), Pune, Offers Students a Global Learning Experience in the UAE Through Joint Certification and Corporate Exposure

Dnyaan Prasad Global University (DPGU), Pune, Offers Students a Global Learning Experience in the UAE Through Joint Certification and Corporate Exposure

November 5, 2026
Dr. Saswat Kumar Ram

Beyond the Classroom: Why Teacher–Student Relationships Matter

November 5, 2026

Categories

  • Agriculture
  • App News
  • Astrology
  • Auto
  • Business
  • Education
  • Entertainment
  • Fashion & Beauty
  • Finance/Money
  • Food
  • Gadgets
  • Health & Fitness
  • Lifestyle
  • National
  • North East News
  • Photography
  • Politics
  • Press Release
  • Religion
  • Science
  • Social Work
  • Sports
  • State News
  • Tech
  • Travel
  • World

About Us

northeastindia.live, digital news and story platform bring you the news, articles, stories, and opinions on the latest happenings worldwide covering various sectors like nation, politics, and governance, social sector, review, foreign affairs, defence and security, latest review, lifestyle, entertainment, sports, technology, auto sectors, education, business and start-ups updates, Agriculture, Science, finance, money, food, and culture, etc.

  • About Us
  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
  • DMCA
  • Follow on Google News

Copyright © 2022 North East India.

No Result
View All Result
  • About Us
  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
  • DMCA
  • Home
  • Privacy Policy

Copyright © 2022 North East India.

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In